With almost monthly, if not weekly, twists and turns in the prognosis on the future of a Europe struggling to cope with a looming sovereign debt crisis and the challenges for long-term economic viability, pundits could be forgiven for being uncertain as to which way the Eurozone and the rest of Europe would be heading.
A YouTube slide presentation by Stefan Molyneux on Freedomain Radio, purportedly the largest and most popular philosophy show on the web, paints a general picture of impending demise. Click here
Molyneux's presentational style is persuasive, backed up by slides full of instrucstive data, although not many people are convinced by his subtle refrain that it's all the fault of "statism"(and he is referring to the West!). It seems that, according to him, if all state interventions and regulations are lifted, all would be well.
In any event, it seems fair to say that notwithstanding some signs of improvement, Europe is by no means out of the woods. Indeed, according to Bob Janjuah at Nomura reported on Business Insider. Europe may well be heading for another global market clash by about 25 - 50%. Click here
A much more authoritative, indepth and insightful analysis is offered by Professor Klaus Schwab, Founder and Executive Chairman of the renowed World Economic Forum, in his thought-provoking e-book "The Re-emergence of Europe" released on 14 December, 2012.
Download Professor Klaus Schwab, WEF - Re-emergence of Europe, December, 2012
Looking back on the recent history of Europe, Professor Schwab argues that the importance of the European project extends far beyond economic integration. It underpins the long-term peace of the continent, as exemplified by the award to Europe of the Nobel Peace Prize 2012.
Professor Schwab points out that nothing less than a trajectory to greater banking and fiscal union, if not political union, would support long-term viability of the Eurozone.
Exit for devalution, however, would create much larger problems that it is purported to solve, according to Professor Schwab. "An overwhelming number of economists, international civil servants and plicy-makers argue that a fragmentation of the eurozone would cause a new depression and massive wealth destruction around the world and would also end the period of economic integration that has characterized world politics since the end of the Second World War."
Notwithstanding huge social reactions and nationalistic divisions, as of October 2012 there has recently been some noticeable movements towards greater convergence. A process of "internal devaluation" of debtor countries in the form of contraction of relative domestic demand has seen significant shrinking of budget deficits and a greater balance between income and expenditure, with sharply falling unit labour costs.
"Consequently, countries such as Ireland, Portugal and Spain have experienced a generally strong performance in exports and are now registering a current-account surplus .... Amazingly, Irish, Portuguese and Spanish export growth has not only kept pace with Germany's in recent years but have out-performed the UK's", Professor Schwab explains.
Contrary to binary thinking - either austerity or growth - Professor Schwab believes that a mixed approach is feasible, including structural reforms particularly in the labour markets, product regulation and a mix of government spending in a growth agenda.
Professor Schwab's prudent prognosis is that "Europe will survive and its currency - the euro - will remain intact, even in a truncated form (if just one country were to exit, for example). After a crisis of several years (possibly up to ten), Euorpean momentum will begin to grow again and will even surprise us positively ..." His relative optimism is based on Europe's unique and valuable assets - generally high-quality human capital and good governance, especially as regards sustainability, and quality and dignity of life.
Many painful and arduous reforms remain to be tackled, to be sure, including creative destruction of a system of excessive welfare entitlements to improve long-term productivity and competitiveness. However, there is no immutable reason why some of the weaker states could not "take the bull by the horns" in emulating Germany's earlier succcessful economic and social reforms.
Many risks and obstacles remain on the way, according to Professor Schwab. He groups them into three broad categories: (1) Political and societal backlash (2) Policy miscalculations and (3) Capital flight and bank runs.
In terms of the social acceptability of reforms, Professor Schwab believes that a turning point has been passed and "from now on .... there are likely to be more surprises in Europe in general, and the Eurozone in particular, on the upside rather than on the downside."
If Professor Schwab's optimism proves to be prescient, as the world's largest economy up to now, a better and more viable Europe, which is "still founded on the same social values and freedoms as before", would have a profound impact on the future world order, and "ultimately for mankind as a whole".